Sonderweg thesis

In his examination of bourgeois social and economic spheres, Blackbourn concedes that the increasingly wealthy German bourgeois were susceptible to the aristocratic lifestyle but argues that this too was not unusual as shown by historian Marin Weiner in his study The Decline of the Industrial Spirit which argues that the British bourgeois class also sought to imitate the aristocracy.

Analyzing the troops of the special police battalion units, who were the ones who directly Sonderweg thesis Jews in the mass raids phase of the Holocaust prior to the death campsBrowning concluded that these typical middle class workers were not ingrained with anti-Semitismbut rather became killers through peer pressure and indoctrination.

Recognizing the importance of modernizing forces in industry and the economy and in the cultural realm, Wehler argues that reactionary traditionalism dominated the political hierarchy of power in Germany, as well as social mentalities and in class relations Klassenhabitus.

Afterthe positive Sonderweg was no longer developed or used. National Socialism was too new to have broken apart the Weimar Republic; it merely picked up the pieces. This type of authoritarianism Sonderweg thesis seen to be avoiding both the autocracy of Imperial Russia and what they regarded as the weak, decadent and ineffective democratic governments of Britain and France.

This supposedly set a unique pattern among European states that resulted in Nazism. Russia must be thrust back as far as possible from Germany's eastern frontier and her domination over the non-Russian vassal peoples broken. Vermeil concluded that Germany will remain on a separate path, "always placing the spirit of its implacable technical discipline at the service of those visions of the future that its eternal romanticisim begets" [4].

Thus, many historians today feel that the Sonderweg theory fails to account for similarities and distinctions with other dictatorships and ethnic cleansings. Is it being unhistorical to judge the anti-Metternichian nationalism and racism of 19th century Germany by its Nazi consequences.

The object of this essay is not to propose a new model for modern German history, but rather to highlight for non-specialists some of the major schools of thought and central arguments related to the concept of Sonderweg.

To what a different future Europe might have looked forward if either Mr. Die Kriegszielpolitik Des Kaiserlichen Deutschland This gave a militaristic approach to German government that lasted through the Weimar Republic and into National Socialism.

Taylor wrote in his book The Course of German History that the Nazi regime "represented the deepest wishes of the German people", and that it was the first and only German government created by the Germans as the Holy Roman Empire had been created by France and Austria, the German Confederation by Austria and Prussia and the Weimar Republic by the Allies [5].

A Study in the Rise of the Germanic Ideology. The hopes to which the Prime Minister had given rise not only compelled him to advocate an unjust and unworkable economic basis to the Treaty with Germany, but set him at variance with the President, and on the other hand with competing interests to those of France and Belgium.

From this point of view, the special path was one that led to disaster. The road from democracy to dictatorship was not a particular German case, but the radical nature of the National Socialist dictatorship corresponded to the power of the German ideology that in — became a political and totalitarian reality [18] In a speech, Hildebrand denied there had been a Sonderweg, and claimed that the Sonderweg only applied to the "special case" of the Nazi dictatorship [19] In a essay, Hildebrand went further and wrote: The German bourgeoisie developed so sluggishly, timidly and slowly that at the moment when it menacingly confronted feudalism and absolutism, it saw menacingly pitted against itself the proletariat and all sections of the middle class whose interests and ideas were related to those of the proletariat… Unlike the French bourgeoisie ofthe Prussian bourgeoisie, when it confronted monarchy and aristocracy, the representatives of the old society, was not a class speaking for the whole of modern society.

At the same time, it had avoided going too far in the other direction and embracing democracy like the British had.

Sonderweg thesis

University of California Press, Shirer in his book The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich argued for the view that German history proceeded logically from "Luther to Hitler" [10]seeing Hitler's rise to power as an expression of German character, rather than of the international phenomenon of totalitarianism.

Their opposition consists of the following points: This would doubtless be accompanied by terrifying scholarly insights and painful human experiences.

Is it a case of the wise-after-the-fallacy to read so much into those early rebels ofwhom many historians still consider great liberals. Criticism[ edit ] The leading critics of the Sonderweg thesis have been two British Marxist historians, Geoff Eley and David Blackbournwho in their book The Peculiarities of German History first published in German in as Mythen deutscher Geschichtsschreibung: In the view of Wehler, Fischer, and their supporters, only the German defeat in put an end to the "premodern" social structure which had led to and then sustained traditional German authoritarianism and its more radical variant, National Socialism.

Therefore, every German desired the achievement which only total war could give. From this point of view, the special path was one that led to disaster. The History of Nazi-Fascist Philosophy Lloyd George or Mr.

To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: The Revolt Against the Revolt that: Wilson had apprehended that the most serious of the problems which claimed their attention were not political or territorial but financial and economic, and that the perils of the future lay not in frontiers or sovereignties but in food, coal, and transport.

Intellectual Origins of the Third Reich. Hans Rosenberg and others argued that preindustrial elites, especially the east Elbian landowners the Junkersupper-level civil servants and the officer corps retained great power and influence well into the twentieth century.

Mosse and Stern both concluded that the intellectual and cultural elites in Germany by and large chose to consciously reject modernity and along with it those groups they identified with modernity, such as Jews, and embraced anti-Semitism as the basis for their Weltanschauung world-view.

Before World War II, there was a slightly different Sonderweg Thesis that was based on the idea that Germany had taken a special path this the meaning of "Sonderweg" to development.

Other historians have argued that nationalism played an especially aggressive, precociously right-wing destructive role during the Second Empire. [Socialism] How did Cuban Government react to the market oriented reforms in China under Deng Xiaoping and USSR under Gorbachev?

How much support and opposition was there towards these policies in the Government and amongst ordinary people?

The weakness of German liberalism usually figures prominently in anything written about modern German history. It is also central to the thesis of a German Sonderweg (separate path), that German history, from at least the nineteenth century onwards, deviated significantly from more benign developments in Western Europe.

The argument is that.


Sonderweg Thesis Sonderweg Thesis Introduction One major dilemma in people's minds regarding Germany is how could a relatively civil country all of a sudden turn towards Nazism and commit so many mass murders for no reason, many analyst and researchers have pondered over this issue until many have stated that the underlying reason.

Jun 01,  · Wehler’s Sonderweg thesis elicited plenty of contrary responses from his contemporaries, and perhaps the pair most often identified as debunkers of Sonderweg were David Blackbourn and Geoff Eley, whose The Peculiarities of German History took aim at some of basic assumptions of Wehler and other Sonderweg historymike.

Sonderweg (German: [ˈzɔndɐˌveːk], "special path") identifies the theory in German historiography that considers the German-speaking lands or the country Germany itself to have followed a course from aristocracy to democracy unlike any other in Europe.

In the opinion of the proponents of the Sonderweg thesis, the crucial turning point was the Revolution ofwhen German liberals failed to seize power and consequently either emigrated or chose to resign themselves to being ruled by a reactionary elite.

Sonderweg thesis
Rated 3/5 based on 87 review
Sonderweg Thesis | Researchomatic